Vintage fashion has something new clothing doesn't have: a story! Vintage pieces are fashionable witnesses of their era and represent uniqueness and timeless elegance. But what happens when someone decides to alter these special pieces? Is the so-called vintage altering ignorant of the history of the clothes or simply an innovative form of it? Upcycling? Here we examine the current discussion from different perspectives and explain the arguments for and against vintage altering.
What exactly does vintage altering mean?
The term vintage altering describes the practice of Vintage clothing or changing accessories to give them a completely new look. Minor corrections such as slight adjustments to the fit for a better fit are excluded. Vintage altering includes, for example, extremely shortening dresses, adding new details, dyeing or painting the clothing or fundamentally changing the cut.
Which pieces fall under the term vintage?
Although the word vintage fashion is often used simply as a synonym for used clothing, it strictly speaking only refers to clothing and accessories that are at least 20 years old. What characterizes these pieces is often their very high quality workmanship compared to today's mass production. Vintage clothing is therefore usually durable, of high quality and is characterized by special details such as hand-embroidered decorations, elaborate buttons or artistic cuts. Every vintage piece has a story and reflects the trends of its time. Vintage fashion encompasses a variety of styles - from the glamorous silhouettes of the 1920s to the iconic pop aesthetic of the 1980s and 1990s.
Source & Copyright by better
The Vintage Altering Controversy: Tradition versus Transformation
How did the debate about vintage aging start?
The debate was sparked by a TikTok post by the British influencer Amelia Liana. In a video, the 31-year-old shows how she shortened a classic vintage Dolce & Gabbana midi dress by around 25 centimeters and turned it into a sexy mini dress. A heated discussion then broke out among her followers in the comment column.
Some of the users are shocked and almost annoyed by the drastic change. "How could you! This is such a crime," writes one follower. "The original was timeless and perfect for many occasions, the modified dress will look even cheaper in a few years than it does now," says another. But there were also positive voices opposing it. “I am absolutely thrilled with this step,” commented one user on the transformation of the vintage piece. “It’s so much more sustainable to do this than to buy something new, and it now has even more personal meaning.”
Why is the discussion so emotional?
The discourse around vintage altering evokes so many emotions because altering vintage clothing touches on personal values that are closely linked to individual beliefs and views about fashion and its history. Whether they're personal pieces like your mother's wedding dress or a rare designer item from the thrift store, these garments are more than just fabric and thread. They are a piece of memory and history.
Source & Copyright by Sloppy seconds
Vintage altering – what speaks for it and what speaks against it?
Can you alter vintage clothing? To answer this question, it is important to look at the discourse from all perspectives. On the one hand there is the loss of originality and therefore the value of the vintage item, on the other hand there is the creative expression and the aspect of sustainability.
Cons – Vintage Altering:
- Loss of historical significance: A vintage piece is like a piece of history to wear. But as a result of the reworking, part of this history is irretrievably lost.
- Appreciation of the original design: Vintage clothing reflects the design and craftsmanship of its time. Altering these pieces is therefore viewed by some vintage fans as disrespectful to the original designers and their legacy.
- Depreciation: Some rare or high quality vintage pieces may lose value if refinished. Collectors and enthusiasts particularly value the originality and authenticity of these items of clothing.
Pro – Vintage Altering:
- Creative new beginning: Reworking vintage clothing allows you to breathe new life into old pieces. Vintage Altering offers a creative way to create a unique and personal style that stands out from the crowd.
- Sustainability: By repurposing old clothing, its life cycle is extended and the need for new garments is reduced. This contributes to Reduction of waste and lower resource consumption at.
- Modern Upgrade: Vintage clothing often does not meet today's fit and style standards. But by changing the old pieces, the old pieces can be perfectly adapted to the wearer, so that the wearer enjoys wearing them often again.
Conclusion: This is how we make a balanced decision
The answer to the question of whether to alter vintage clothing lies in the balance between personal expression, the pursuit of sustainability and preserving a unique fashion item as part of cultural heritage. Everyone has to decide for themselves how to weight the different aspects. Is it a ready-to-wear piece from standardized production or a tailor-made couture piece? What personal memories do I associate with the piece? Will it still have its timeless character even after the change, so that I can wear it for a lifetime?
One thing is certain: the longer the life cycle of a vintage garment, the better it is for our environment. Even if the originality is lost through vintage altering, the story of the garment can be continued and a whole new chapter is even added.
